Discussion: “An Integral Equation for the Dual-Lag Model of Heat Transfer” (Kulish, V. V., and Novozhilov, V. B., 2004, ASME J. Heat Transfer, 126, pp. 805–808) PUBLIC ACCESS

[+] Author and Article Information
D. Milov

 RRA, 56 Burlington Street, Lexington, MA 02420

J. Heat Transfer 129(7), 927 (Jan 30, 2006) (1 page) doi:10.1115/1.2227044 History: Received May 26, 2005; Revised January 30, 2006

In this paper, the authors claim in the abstract and the conclusion that the “solution with dual phase lag depends only on the difference between the two lags.” Then, they proceed to derive an integral solution for the temperature history.

I show first that this conclusion is erroneous and second that the Laplace transform method they use is incorrect.

The authors claim that the system of the dual lag Eqs. (1) and (3) in their paper is equivalent to the new system of Eqs. (6) and (7) in their paper. This is quite incorrect for the following reasons:
  • To obtain Eq. (6) from Eq. (1), the authors perform the shift in time told+τqtnew, where told corresponds to the time in Eq. (1) and tnew is the time in Eq. (6).With this shift Eq. (3) becomes using the new time
    whereas the authors assume that Eq. (3) does not change with the transformation of time applied to obtain Eq. (6) from Eq. (1).
  • It follows that the derivation of Eq. (7) is wrong. Equation (7) is correct only if τq=0.

Thus, their conclusion that the “solution with dual phase lag depends only on the difference between the two lags” is wrong.

The solution that follows Eq. (7) can be applicable only when τq=0 as pointed out in the previous discussion. In this case, Eq. (8) is fine but its Laplace transform Eq. (10) is not.

To find the Laplace of Eq. (8), we multiply both sides by est and then integrate over time from Δτ to infinity following the notation in the subject paper.

The result is not Eq. (10) as the authors claim but the following equation


Here the Laplace transform of the temperature rise is defined as


I suggest that the subject paper be retracted.

Copyright © 2007 by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
This article is only available in the PDF format.






Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In