Abstract
Greater understanding of animal scavenging of human remains can assist forensic science investigators in locating and recovering dispersed skeletal elements, in recognizing damage produced by scavengers, and in making more informed estimates of the postmortem interval. The pattern of skeletal damage can indicate whether the body was scavenged while intact or at some time after other natural processes of disarticulation had begun.
This study analyzed thirty partially to fully skeletonized human remains with respect to scavenging at the time of body discovery in order to determine if a patterned consumption sequence existed. The scavengers were primarily coyotes (Canis latrans) and domestic dogs (C. familiaris). Sixteen non-carnivore-scavenged remains were also examined and contrasted with the carnivore-scavenged sample.
Observed postmortem intervals from death to recovery ranged from 4 h to 52 months. Results demonstrate that canid scavenging of human remains takes place in sequential stages: Stage 0 = no bony involvement; Stage 1 = ventral thorax damaged and one or both upper extremities removed; Stage 2 = lower extremity involvement; Stage 3 = only vertebral segments remain articulated; and Stage 4 = total disarticulation. Results revealed a clear correspondence between observed stages of disarticulation and the postmortem interval.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
Sorg
, M. H.
, “Scavenger Modifications of Human Skeletal Remains in Forensic Anthropology
,” presented at the 38th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, New Orleans, LA
, 10–15 Feb. 1986.2.
Rodriguez
, W. C.
, “Postmortem Animal Activity, Recognition and Interpretation
,” presented at the 39th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, San Diego, CA
, 16–21 Feb. 1987.3.
Morse
, D.
, Duncan
, J.
, and Stoutmire
, J. W.
, Handbook of Forensic Archeology
, Rose Printing Co.
, Tallahassee, FL
, 1983
, pp. 148
-153
.4.
Haglund
, W. D.
, Reay
, D. T.
, and Swindler
, D. R.
, “Tooth Artifacts and Survival of Bones in Animal-Scavenged Human Skeletons
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 33
, No. 4
, 07
1988
, pp. 985
-997
.5.
Hill
, A. P.
, “Disarticulation and Scattering of Mammal Skeletons
,” Paleobiology
0094-8373, Vol. 5
, No. 3
, 1979
, pp. 261
-274
.6.
Rhine
, S.
, Curran
, B.
, Boydstun
, S.
, Churchill
, S.
, Ivey
, P.
, and Oglivie
, M.
, “Skeletonization Rates in the Desert
,” abstract from program of the 40th Annual Meeting of American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, Philadelphia, PA
, 15–20 Feb. 1988.7.
Brain
, C. K.
, “Parts of the Skeleton: Survival and Disappearance
,” The Hunters and the Hunted
. University of Chicago Press
, Chicago
, 1981
, pp. 11
-29
, 109
-117
.8.
Behrensmeyer
, A. K.
, “Time Resolutions in Fluvial Vertebrate Assemblages
,” Paleobiology
0094-8373, Vol. 8
, 1982
, pp. 211
-227
.9.
Behrensmeyer
, A. K.
, “Patterns of Natural Bone Disarticulation on Recent Land Surfaces: Implications for Archeological Site Formation
,” Animals and Archeology
, Vol. 1
, J.
Clutton Brock
and C.
Grigson
, Eds., Oxford B.A.R.
, U.K.
, 1983
, pp. 93
-106
.10.
Crader
, D. C.
, “Recent Single-carcass Bone Scatters and the Problem of ‘Butchery’ Sites in the Archeological Record
,” Animals and Archeology
. Vol. 1
, J. C.
Brock
and C.
Grigson
, Eds., Oxford B.A.R.
, U.K.
, 1983
, pp. 107
-141
, 1093.11.
Brooks
, S.
and Brooks
, R. H.
, “Effects on Bone of Abrasive Contents in Moving Water
,” presented at the 1st International Conference on Bone Modification
, Carson City, NV
, 08
1984
.12.
Haynes
, G.
, “Utilization and Skeletal Disturbances of North American Prey Carcasses
,” Arctic
0004-0843, Vol. 35
, No. 2
, 1982
, pp. 226
-281
.13.
Haynes
, G.
, “Prey Bones and Preditors: Potential Ecologic Information from Analysis of Bone Sites
,” Ossa
, Vol. 7
, 1980
, pp. 75
-97
.14.
Behrensmeyer
, A. K.
, “Taphonomic and Ecologic Information from Bone Weathering
,” Paleobiology
0094-8373, Vol. 4
, No. 2
, 1978
, pp. 150
-162
.15.
Tappen
, N. C.
, “The Relationship of Weathering Cracks to Split-line Orientation in Bone
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 31
, pp. 191
-198
.16.
Hill
, A. P.
, “On Carnivore and Weathering Damage to Bones
,” Current Anthropology
0011-3204, Vol. 17
, pp. 335
-336
.17.
Willey
, P.
and L.
M. Snyder
, “Canid Modifications of Human Remains: Implications for Time Since Death Estimations
,” Abstract from program of 40th Annual Meeting of American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, Philadelphia, PA
, 15–20 Feb. 1988.18.
Haynes
, G.
, “Evidence of Carnivore Gnawing in Pleistocene and Recent Mammalian Bones
,” Paleobiology
0094-8373, Vol. 6
, No. 3
, 1980
, pp. 341
-351
.19.
Haynes
, G.
, “On Watering Holes, Mineral Licks, Death, and Predation
,” Environments and Extinctions: Man in Late Glacial North America
, J. F.
Mead
and D. J.
Meltzer
, Eds., University of Maine at Orona, Orona, ME, Center for the Study of Early Man
, Orona, ME
, 1985
, pp. 53
-71
.20.
Warren
, C. P.
, “Plants as Decomposition Vectors Human Skeletal Remains
,” abstract from program of 32nd Annual Meeting of American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, New Orleans
, 20–23 Feb. 1980.21.
Binford
, L.
, Bones: Ancient Men and Modern Myths
, Academic Press
, New York
, 1981
, pp. 49
-51
.22.
Toots
, H.
, “Sequence of Disarticulation in Mammalian Skeletons
,” University of Wyoming Contributions in Geology
, Vol. 4
, No. 1
, 01
1965
, pp. 37
-39
.23.
Stewart
, T. D.
, Essentials of Forensic Anthropology
, Charles C Thomas
, Springfield, IL
, 1979
, p. 70.24.
Spitz
, W. U.
and Fisher
, R. S.
, Medicolegal Investigation of Death
, Charles C Thomas
, Springfield, IL
, 1980
, p. 18.25.
Krogman
, W. M.
and Iscan
, M. Y.
, The Human Skeleton in Forensic Medicine
, Charles C Thomas
, Springfield, IL
, 1986
, p. 23.26.
Reed
, H. B.
, “A Study of Pig Carcass Communities in Tennessee, with Special Reference to Insects
,” American Midland Naturalist
, Vol. 59
, 1958
, pp. 213
-245
.27.
Payne
, J. A.
, “A Summer Carrion Study of the Pig Sus scrofa
,” Ecology
0012-9658, Vol. 46
, No. 5
, 1965
, pp. 592
-602
.28.
Payne
, J. A.
, King
, E. W.
, and Beinhart
, G.
, “Arthropod Succession and Decomposition of Buried Pigs
,” Nature
0028-0836, London, Vol. 219
, No. 5159
, 1968
, pp. 1180
-1181
.29.
Payne
, J. A.
and King
, E. W.
, “Insect Succession and Decomposition of Pig Carcasses in Water
,” Journal of the Gorgia Entomological Society
, Vol. 7
, 1972
, pp. 153
-162
.30.
Rodriguez
, W. C.
and Bass
, W. M.
, “On Insect Activity and its Relationship to Decay Rates of Human Cadavers in East Tennessee
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 28
, No. 2
, 04
1983
, pp. 423
-432
.31.
Smith
, K. G.
, A Manual Forensic Entymology
. Cornell University Press
, Oxford, U.K.
, 1986
.32.
Rodriguez
, W. C.
, “Evidence of Decomposition: Its Use in the Interpretation of the Death Scene and Recovery of Skeletal Remains
,” abstract of Program of 40th Annual Meeting of American Academy of Forensic Science
, Philadelphia, PA
, 15–20 Feb. 1988.33.
Shafer
, W.
, The Ecology and Paleocology on Marine Environments
, University of Chicago Press
, Chicago
, 1978
.34.
Rodriguez
, W. C.
and Bass
, W. M.
, “Decomposition of Buried Bodies and Methods That May Aid in Their Location
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 30
, No. 3
, 07
1985
, pp. 836
-852
.35.
Dodson
, P.
, “The Significance of Small Bones in Paleological Interpretation
,” Contributions to Geology
, Vol. 12
, No. 1
, 1973
, pp. 15
-19
.36.
Blumenschine
, R. J.
, “Early Hominid Scavenging Opportunities
,” British Archeological Reports International Series, No. 283
, Oxford, U.K.
, 1986
.37.
Blumenschine
, R. J.
, “Carcass Consumption Sequences and the Archeological Distinction of Scavenging and Hunting
,” Journal of Human Evolution
0047-2484, Vol. 15
, No. 8
, 1986
, pp. 639
-659
.38.
Local Climatological Data: 1982–1986 Annual Summaries With Comparative Data
, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, U.S. Department of Commerce National Climatic Data Center
, Ashville, N.C.
, 1982–1986.39.
1986 King County Annual Growth Report
, Department of Development and Community Planning
, Seattle, WA, 1986
.40.
Haynes
, G.
, “Prey Bones and Preditors: Potential Ecologic Information from Analysis of Bone Sites
,” Ossa
, Vol. 7
, 1980
, pp. 75
-97
.41.
Aldenderfer
, M. S.
and Blashfield
, R. R.
, “Cluster Analysis
, Stage Publications
, Beverly Hills, CA
, 1986
, pp. 43
-45
.42.
Haglund
, W. D.
, Reay
, D. T.
, and C.
C. Snow
, “Identification of Serial Homicide Victims in the ‘Green River Murder’ Investigation
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 32
, No. 6
, 11
1988
, pp. 1666
-1675
.43.
Adelson
, L.
, The Pathology of Homicide
, Charles C Thomas
, Springfield, IL
, 1974
, p. 390.44.
Rodriguez
, W.
, “Time Since Death and Interpretation of Postmortem Artifacts
,” presented at the 1986 Annual Meeting of the National Association of Medical Examiners
, 18–22 Nov. 1986.45.
Birkby
, W. H.
and Galloway
, A.
, “Decay Rates in an Arid Environment
,” presented at the 40th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, Philadelphia, PA
, 15–20 Feb. 1988.46.
Warren
, C. D.
, “The Recovery of Human Remains: The Weakest Link in the Chain of Forensic Evidence
,” presented at the 36th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, Anaheim, CA
, 21–25 Feb. 1984.47.
Howard
, J. D.
, Reay
, D. T.
, Haglund
, W. D.
, and Fligner
, C. L.
, “Processing of Skeletal Remains: A Medical Examiner's Perspective
,” American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology
0195-7910, Vol. 9
, No. 3
, 09
1988
, pp. 258
-264
.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.
