Abstract
Advances in STR PCR DNA profiling technology allow for the analysis of minute quantities of DNA. It is frequently possible to obtain successful DNA results from cellular material transferred from the skin of an individual who has simply touched an object. Handling objects, such as weapons or other items associated with a crime, touching surfaces, or wearing clothing, may represent sufficient contact to transfer small numbers of DNA bearing cells, or trace DNA, which can be successfully analyzed. With this minimal amount of contact required to yield a suspect profile comes tremendous crime solving potential, and a number of considerations for prudent application, and the maximization of evidentiary value. Evidentiary materials not previously considered must be recognized and preserved, and the resulting DNA type profiles interpreted in their proper forensic context.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
Gill
P
, Jeffreys
AJ
, Werrett
DJ
. Forensic application of DNA “fingerprints.”
Nature
0028-0836 1985
;318
:577
–9
.2.
Jeffreys
AJ
, Wilson
V
, Thein
SL
. Individual-specific “fingerprints” of human DNA
. Nature
0028-0836 1985
;316
:76
–9
.3.
Sensabaugh
GF
. Biochemical markers of individuality
. Forensic Science Handbook, ed. R.
Saferstein
. New Jersey
: Prentice-Hall
. 1982
:338
–415
.4.
Beckmann
, JS
, Weber
, JL
. Survey of human and rat microsatellites
. Genomics
1992
;12
:627
–31
.5.
Saiki
RK
, Gelfand
DH
, Stoffel
S
, Scharf
SJ
, Higuchi
R
, Horn
GT
, et al. Primer-directed enzymatic amplification of DNA with a thermostable DNA polymerase
. Science
0036-8075 1988
;239
:487
–91
.6.
Mayrand
PE
, Corcoran
KP
, Ziegle
JS
, Robertson
JM
, Hoff
LB
, Kronick
MN
. The use of fluorescence detection and internal lane standards to size PCR products automatically
. Applied and Theoretical Electrophoresis
1992
;3
:1
–11
.7.
Klimpton
CP
, Gill
P
, Walton
A
, Urquhart
A
, Millican
ES
, Adams
M
. Automated DNA profiling employing multiplex amplification of short tandem repeat loci
. PCR Methods and Applications
1993
;3
:13
–22
.8.
Higuchi
CH
, vonBeroldingen
GF
, Sensabaugh
GF
, Erlich
HA
. DNA typing from single hairs
. Nature
0028-0836 1988
;332
:543
–6
.9.
Hochmeister
MN
, Budowle
B
, Jung
J
, Borer
UV
, Comey
CT
, Dirnhofer
R
. PCR-based typing of DNA extracted from cigarette butts
. Internat. J Leg Med
1991
;104
:229
–33
.10.
Hagelberg
E
, Sykes
B
. Ancient bone DNA amplified
. Nature
0028-0836 1989
;342
–485
.11.
Clayton
TM
, Whitaker
JP
, Maguire
CN
. Identification of bodies from the scene of a mass disaster using DNA amplification of short tandem repeat (STR) loci
. Forensic Sci Int
0379-0738 1995
;76
:7
–15
.12.
Wickenheiser
RA
, MacMillan
CE
, Challoner
CM
. Case of identification of severely burned human remains via paternity testing with PCR DNA typing
. Can Soc Forensic Sci J
1999
;32
(1
):15
–24
.13.
Haglund
WD
, Reay
DT
, Tepper
SL
. Identification of decomposed human remains by deoxyribunucleic acid (DNA) profiling
. J Forensic Sci
1990
;35
:724.14.
Giusti
A
, Baird
M
, Pasquale
M
, Balazs
I
, Glassberg
J
. Application of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) polyorphisms to the analysis of DNA recovered from sperm
. J Forensic Sci
1986
;31
:409.15.
Dimo-Simonin
N
, Grange
F
, Brandt-Caasadevall
C
. PCR-based forensic testing of DNA from stained cytological smears
. J Forensic Sci
1997
;42
(3
):207
–27
.16.
Schwartz
TR
, Schwartz
EA
, Mieszerski
L
, McNally
L
, Kobilinsky
L
. Characterization of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) obtained from teeth subjected to various environmental conditions
. J Forensic Sci
1991
;36
(4
):979
–90
.17.
Herber
B
, Herold
K
. DNA typing of human dandruff
. J Forensic Sci
1998
;43
(3
):648
–56
.18.
Brinkmann
B
, Rand
S
, Bajanowski
T
. Forensic identification of urine samples
. Int J Leg Med
1992
;105
:59
–61
.19.
Sweet
D
, Shutler
GG
. Analysis of salivary DNA evidence from a bite mark on a body submerged in water
. J Forensic Sci
1999
;44
(5
):1069
–72
.20.
Tanaka
M
, Yoshimoto
T
, Nozawa
H
, Ohtaki
H
, Kato
Y
, Sato
K
, et al. Usefulness of a toothbrush as a source of evidential DNA for typing
. J Forensic Sci
2000
;45
(3
):674
–6
.21.
van Oorschot
, RAH
, Jones
MK
. DNA fingerprints from fingerprints
. Nature
0028-0836 1997
;387
:787.22.
Wiegand
P
, Kleiber
M
. DNA typing of epithelial cells after strangulation
. J Legal Med
1997
;110
:181
–3
.23.
Wickenheiser
RA
, Challoner
CM
. Latest developments in PCR DNA technology provides sensitive new tool for investigators—but be careful
. Royal Canadian Mounted Police North West Region-Forensic Laboratory
Broadcast
1997
:November.24.
Wickenheiser
RA
, Challoner
CM
. Suspect DNA profiles obtained from the handles of weapons recovered at crime scenes
. Proceedings of the 10th Annual Symposium on Human Identification, Lake Buena Vista, Florida
, 10
1999
.25.
Szakacs
NA
, MacMillan
CE
, Roney
JM
, Wickenheiser
RA
, Hummel
KHJ
, Kuperus
WR
, et al. Perspectives on DNA casework: unusual exhibits, mixture interpretation, and profiles from inhibited PCR reactions
. Poster presentation—11th Annual Symposium on Human Identification, Biloxi, Mississippi
, Oct 10–13, 2000.26.
Hummel
KHJ
, Wickenheiser
RA
, Roney
JM
, Szakacs
NA
, MacMillan
CE
, Kuperus
WR
, et al. Update on unusual exhibit material yielding successful DNA profiles using PCR STR typing
. Poster Presentation—4th Annual Cambridge Healthtech Institute's DNA Forensics Conference, Springfield, Virginia
, May 31–June 2, 2000.27.
Wickenheiser
RA
, Roney
JM
, Hummel
KHJ
, Szakacs
NA
, MacMillan
CE
, Kuperus
WR
, et al. Unusual exhibit material yielding successful DNA profiles using PCR STR typing
. Poster Presentation—Proceedings of the 10th Annual Symposium on Human Identification, Lake Buena Vista, Florida
, October, 1999.28.
Hummel
KH
, Biology Section, RCMP Forensic Laboratory, 6101 Dewdney Ave. W., Regina
, Saskatchewan, Canada, S4P 3J7. Personal communication.29.
Wickenheiser
RA
, DeGouffe
MJ
. DNA on steering wheels. Preliminary feasibility study
. Unpublished. Biology Section, RCMP Forensic Laboratory
, Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada, S4P 3J7
, 1999
.30.
Roney
JM
, Biology Section, RCMP Forensic Laboratory
, 6101 Dewdney Ave. W., Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada, S4P 3J7. Personal communication.31.
Szakacs
NA
, Biology Section, RCMP Forensic Laboratory
, 6101 Dewdney Ave. W., Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada, S4P 3J7. Personal communication.32.
Wickenheiser
RA
, Jobin
RM
. Case of comparison of DNA recovered from a contact lens using PCR DNA typing
. Can Soc Forensic Sci J
1999
;32
(2
,3
):67
–73
.33.
MacMillan
CE
, Biology Section, Maine State Police Crime Laboratory
, 30 Hospital Street, Augusta, Maine, 04333-0133, Personal communication.34.
Raven
PH
, Johnson
GB
. Biology
. Times Mirror/Mosby College Publishing
, St.Louis
, 1986
:906.35.
Darnell
, JE
, Lodish
HF
, Baltimore
D
. Cell biology
. Scientific American
, New York
, 1986
:137.36.
Locard
E
. The analysis of dust traces—Part I
. Am J Pol Sci
1930
;1
:276
–98
.37.
Whitehead
PH
, Kipps
AE
. A test paper for detecting saliva stains
. J Forensic Sci Soc
1975
;15
:39
–42
.38.
Duke-Elder
S
. The anatomy of the visual system, in system of opthamology
. Volume II
. London, England
: Henry Kimpton Publishers
1976
:96
–113
.39.
Bellefeuille
J
, Bowen
K
, Wilkinson
D
, Yamashita
B
. Crime scene protocols for DNA evidence
. Forensic Ident Research and Review Sec. (FIRRS), RCMP Head Quarters
, 1200 Vanier Parkway, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, K1A 0R2
: 1999
:45.40.
Ladd
C
, Adamowicz
MS
, Bourke
MT
, Scherczinger
CA
, Lee
HC
. A systematic analysis of secondary DNA transfer
. J Forensic Sci
1999
:44
(6
):1270
–2
.41.
Kisilevsky
AE
, Wickenheiser
RA
. DNA PCR profiling of skin cells transferred through handling
. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Canadian Society of Forensic Science, Edmonton, Alberta
, November 17–20, 1999.42.
Zamir
A
, Springer
E
, Glattstein
B
. Fingerprints and DNA: STR typing of DNA extracted from adhesive tape processing for fingerprints
. J Forensic Sci
2000
;45
(3
):687
–8
.43.
Shutler
GG
. A study on the inter-relationship between fingerprint developing techniques and bloodstain identification and typing methods
. Can Soc Forensic Sci J
1980
;13
:1
–8
.44.
Duncan
GT
, Seiden
H
, Vallee
L
, Ferraro
D
. Effects of superglue, other fingerprint developing agents, luminol on bloodstain analysis
. J Assoc Off Anal Chem
1986
;69
:677
–80
.45.
Lee
HC
, Gaensslen
RE
, Pagliaro
EM
, Guman
MB
, Berka
KM
, Keith
TP
, et al. The effect of the presumptive test, latent fingerprint and some other reagents and materials on subsequent serological identification, genetic marker and DNA testing in bloodstains
. J Forensic Ident
1989
;39
:339
–57
.46.
Laux
DL
. Effects of luminol on the subsequent analysis of bloodstains
. J Forensic Sci
1991
;36
:1512
–20
.47.
Hockmeister
MN
, Budowle
B
, Baechtel
FS
. Effects of presumptive test reagents on the ability to obtain restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) patterns from human blood and semen stains
. J Forensic Sci
1991
;36
:656
–61
.48.
Shipp
E
, Roelofs
R
, Togneri
E
, Wright
R
, Atkinson
D
, Henry
B
. Effects of argon laser light, alternate source light, and cyanoacrylate fuming on DNA typing of human bloodstains
. J Forensic Sci
1993
;38
:184
–91
.49.
Stein
C
, Kyeck
SH
, Henssge
C
. DNA typing of fingerprint reagent treated biological stains
. J Forensic Sci
1996
;41
:1012
–7
.50.
Anderson
J
, Bramble
S
. The effects of fingermark enhancement light sources on subsequent PCR-STR DNA analysis of fresh bloodstains
. J Forensic Sci
1997
;42
:303
–6
.51.
Fregeau
CJ
, Germain
O
, Fourney
RM
. Fingerprint enhancement revisited and the effects of blood enhancement chemicals on subsequent Profiler Plus TM fluorescent short tandem repeat DNA analysis of fresh and aged bloody fingerprints
. J Forensic Sci
2000
;45
(2
):354
–80
.52.
Jobin
RM
, DeGouffe
MJ
. The persistence of seminal constituents on undershorts after laundering: significance of investigations of sexual assaults
, Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Canadian Society of Forensic Science, Edmonton, Alberta
, November 17–20, 1999.53.
Crowe
G
, Moss
D
, Elliott
D
. The effect of laundering on the detection of acid phosphatase and permatazoa on cotton T-shirts
, Can Soc Forensic Sci J
2000
;33
(1
):1
–5
.54.
Szakacs
, NA
, Challoner
, CA
, Sauve
V
, Two success stories, using PCR technology to obtain DNA evidence from unlikely sources
. Can Soc Forensic Sci J
Vol 1997
;30
:170.55.
Sullivan
K
. Future improvements in the utility of DNA profiling as an intelligence tool
. Presented at the 11th Annual Symposium on Human Identification, Biloxi, Mississippi
, Oct 10–13, 2000.56.
Behun
J
, Chief of Forensic Science Systems Unit, FBI Lab
, 935 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, GRB Suite 3R, Washington, D.C., 20535. Personal communication.57.
Bereti
R
. Young Offender Program Supervisor, Department of Social Services, Government of Saskatchewan
, Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada. Personal communication.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.
