Abstract

I am pleased that the original article on eyeball projection has generated interest and critical review by E. Craig, however, she does not support her suggestions with evidence. The literature clearly states that the mid-orbital tangent guideline specifically predicts the “outer point of the cornea” (1) p. 266, (2) p. 429, (3) p. 381, (4) p. 429, (5) p. 29, or the "apex of the cornea" (6) p. 328. Given E. Craig's comments, either the original guideline, although inaccurate (7), was intended to be used for globe positioning using the cornea as cited over the past 40 years (1–6) (note as recently as last year); or there has been initially, or at some later stage, a misunderstanding of basic anatomical terminology, with the iris being mistaken for the cornea; or changes have been made to the traditional globe projection guideline on a post-hoc basis by using the iris to “explain away” error in the original published guideline.

References

1.
Krogman
WM
.
The human skeleton in forensic medicine
.
Illinois
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1962
.
2.
Krogman
WM
,
Iscan
MY
.
The human skeleton in forensic medicine
.
Illinois
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1986
.
3.
Taylor
KT
.
Two-dimensional facial reconstruction from the skull
. In:
Taylor
KT
, ed.
Forensic Art and Illustration
.
Boca Raton
,
CRC Press
2001
;
361
417
.
4.
Gatliff
BP
,
Taylor
KT
.
Three-dimensional facial reconstruction on the skull
. In:
Taylor
KT
, ed.
Forensic art and illustration
.
Boca Raton
,
CRC Press
2001
;
419
75
.
5.
Gatliff
BP
,
Snow
CC
.
From skull to visage
.
J Biocommun
 0094-2499
1979
;
6
:
27
30
.
6.
Gatliff
BP
.
Facial sculpture on the skull for identification
.
Am J Forensic Med Pathol
 0195-7910
1984
;
5
:
327
32
.
7.
Stephan
CN
.
Facial approximation: falsification of globe projection guideline by exophthalmometry literature
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2002
;
47
:
1
6
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.